A lot of people worry about information security, and perhaps rightly so. We are steadily plagued by ransomware, data breaches, phishing attacks and password stealers; being reminded of good security habits regularly is generally a good thing. Normally, this does not result on angry people. Except for on the Internet of course, and perhaps in particular on Twitter, the platform made for online rage.
Here’s a recent Tweet from infosec awareness blogger John Opdenakker (you can read his blog here https://johnopdenakker.com):
If you click this one you will get some responses, including some harsh ones:
And another one. Felt like an attack, perhaps it was an attack?
So far the disagreement is not quite clear, just that some people obviously think VPN’s are of little use for privacy and security (and I tend to agree). There are of course nicer ways of stating such opinions. I even tried to meddle, hopefully in a somewhat less tense voice. Or maybe not?
This didn’t really end too well, I guess this was the end of it (not directed at me but at @desdotdev.
This is not a very good way to discuss something. My 2 cents here, beyond “be nice to each other”, was really just a link to this quite good argument why commercial VPN’s are mostly not very useful (except if you want to bypass geoblocking or hide your ip from the websites you visit):
Risks and VPN marketing
For a good writeup on VPN’s not making you secure, I suggest you read the gist above. Of course, everything depends on everything, and in particular your threat model does. If you fear that evil hackers are sitting on your open WiFi network and looking at all your web traffic to non-https sites, sure, a VPN will protect you. But most sites use HTTPS, and if it is a bank or something similar they will also use HSTS (which makes sure the initial connection is safe too). So what are the typical risks of the coffee shop visiting internet browsing person?
- Email: malware and phishing emails trying to trick you into sharing too much information or installing malware
- Magecart infected online shopping venues
- Shoulder surfers reading your love letters from the chair behind you
- Someone stealing your phone or laptop while you are trying to fetch that cortado
- Online bullying threatening your mental health while discussing security awareness on Twitter
- Secret Chinese agents spying on your dance moves on TikTok
Does a VPN help here? No, it doesn’t. It encrypts the traffic between your computer, and a computer controlled by the VPN company. Such companies typically register in countries with little oversight. Usually the argument is “to avoid having to deliver any data to law enforcement” and besides “we don’t keep logs of anything”. Just completely by coincidence the same countries tend to be tax havens that allows you to hide corporate owner structures as well. Very handy. So, instead of trusting your ISP, you set up a tunnel to a computer entirely controlled by a company owned by someone you don’t know, in a jurisdiction that allows them to do so without much oversight, where they promise not to log anything. I am not sure this is a win for privacy or security. And it doesn’t help against China watching your TikTok videos or a Magecart gang stealing your credit card information on your favourite online store.
One of the more popular VPN providers is ExpressVPN. They provide a 10-step security test, which asks mostly useful questions about security habits (although telling random web pages your preferred messaging app, search engine and browser may not be the best idea) – and it also asks you “do you use a VPN”. If you answer “no” – here’s their security advice for you:
It is true that it will make it hard to snoop on you on an open wireless network. But this is not in most people’s threat models – not really. The big problems are usually those in our bullet point list above. ExpressVPN is perhaps one of the least scare-mongering VPN sellers, and even they try to scare you into “but security/privacy anxiety” buying their product. The arguments about getting around geoblocking and hiding your ip from the websites you visit are OK – if you have a need to do that. Most people don’t.
When VPN’s tell you to buy their service to stay safe online, they are addressing a very narrow online risk driver – that is negligible in most people’s threat models.
So what should I do when browsing at a coffee shop?
If you worry about the network itself, a VPN may be a solution to that, provided you trust the VPN itself. You could run your own VPN with a cloud provider if you want to and like to do technical stuff. Or, you could just use your phone to connect to the internet if you have a reasonable data plan. I would rather trust a regulated cell provider than an unregulated anonymous corporation in the Caribbean.
Email, viruses and such: be careful with links and attachments, run endpoint security and keep your computer fully up to date. This takes you a long way, and a VPN does not help at all!
Magecart: this one can be hard to spot, use a credit card when shopping online, and check your statements carefully every month. If your bank provides a virtual card with one-time credit card numbers that is even better. Does a VPN help? No.
Theft of phones, laptops and coffee mugs? Keep an eye on your stuff. Does a VPN help? Nope.
Online bullying? Harder to fight this one but don’t let them get to you. Perhaps John is onto something here? If you feel harassed, use the block button 🙂
Secret Chinese agents on TikTok? No solution there, except not showing your dance moves on TikTok. Don’t overshare. Does a VPN help? Probably not.
2 thoughts on “Commercial VPN’s: the Twitter security awareness flamewar edition”
I can understand why VPNs are preferred by many, but in my experience, many of them are too expensive for what they provide. I believe it’s better to simply be cautious of the networks you connect with when you’re out and about.
Yes, that is a good approach but it all depends on your use case! For getting around geoblocking commercial VPN’s are effective. For security it depends on your threat model: you put a lot of trust in that VPN service. If your life depends on your OPSEC, other measures are probably better 🙂